The Groupe de recherche en philosophie politique de Montréal (GRIPP) is pleased to announce the 2016 winner of the Annual Montreal Political Theory Manuscript Workshop Award: “Reinventing Morality: A History of American Political Thought since the 1950s,” by Katrina Forrester of the Queen Mary University of London. A workshop on the manuscript will be held at McGill University in May 2016 (TBD).
December 15, 2015
Old Chancellor Day Hall Room 16, Law Faculty
|The Groupe de recherche interuniversitaire en philosophie politique de Montréal, the Centre de recherche en éthique, and the Research Group on Constitutional Studies are pleased to announce a day-long workshop on Arash Abizadeh’s book manuscript “Hobbes and the Two Dimensions of Normativity.”
|Le Groupe de recherche interuniversitaire en philosophie politique de Montréal, le Centre de recherche en éthique, et le Research Group on Constitutional Studies ont le plaisir d’annoncer un atelier d’une journée complète sur le manuscrit d’Arash Abizadeh, entitulé « Hobbes and the Two Dimensions of Normativity ».
|Format: To maximize the quality of discussion, participants are expected to have read the manuscript beforehand. The workshop comprises four sessions dedicated to the manuscript. Each session will begin with brief critiques of chapters of the manuscript, followed by a brief response by the author and general discussion.
|Format : pour maximiser la qualité des discussions, on demande aux participants de lire le manuscrit au préalable. L’atelier comprendra quatre séances de discussions critiques sur le manuscrit ; chacune d’entre elles commencera sera lancée par des commentaires critiques d’une des sections du manuscrit, suivi d’une courte réponse de l’auteur et d’une discussion générale.
|Registration: The workshop is open to everyone, but attendance is by registration and limited in number. RSVP the workshop coordinator: Cameron Cotton O’Brien <cameron.cotton-obrien at mail.mcgill.ca>||Inscription : L’atelier est ouvert à tous, mais l’inscription préalable est requise étant donné le nombre limité de places. RSVP le coordinateur de l’atelier : Cameron Cotton O’Brien <cameron.cotton-obrien àmail.mcgill.ca>
|Manuscript: Click here for access to manuscript. Access requires a password, which all participants will receive upon registration. (If you experience difficulty opening the PDF, ensure that your browser opens the file with the latest version of Adobe Acrobat Reader.)||Manuscrit: Cliquez ici pour l’accès au manuscrit. Vous aurez besoin d’un mot de passe, que vous aurez recevoir quand vous vous inscrivez. (Si vous avez de la difficulté à ouvrir le PDF, notez que vous aurez besoin de Adobe Acrobat Reader.)|
|8:45 – 9:00||Welcome / accueil
|9 – 10:30||1. Introduction
|Chair /président:||Christian Nadeau (philosophie, Montréal)|
|Commentators /commentateurs:||1. Sarah Stroud (philosophy, McGill)
2.Terence Cuneo (philosophy, Vermont)
|10:30 – 10:45||Coffee Break / pause café
|10:45 – 12:15||3. Mind, Action, and Reasoning
4. Subjectivism, Instrumentalism, and Prudentialism about Reasons
|Chair / président:||Dario Perinetti (philosophie, UQAM)|
|Commentators /commentateurs:||3. Laurens van Apeldoorn (philosophy, Leiden)
4. Stephen Darwall (philosophy, Yale)
|12:15 – 13:30||Lunch / Dîner
|13:30 – 15:00||5. A Theory of the Good: Felicity by Anticipatory Pleasure
6. Accountability and Second-personal Reasons
|Chair / présidente:||Dominique Leydet (philosophie, UQAM)|
|Commentators / commentateurs:||5. Kinch Hoekstra (politics, Berkeley)
6. Evan Fox-Decent (law, McGill)
|15:00 – 15:15||Coffee Break / pause café
|15:15 – 17:00||7. Morality, the Laws of Nature, and Justice
8. Rational Agency versus Personhood
|Chair / président:||Daniel Weinstock (law, McGill)|
|Commentators / commentateurs:||7. Susanne Sreedhar (philosophy, Boston)
8. Travis Smith (politics, Concordia)
|19:00||Dinner / Souper|
|About: Since the manuscript partly considers Hobbes’s ethics in light of recent philosophical treatments of normativity, the workshop brings together both Hobbes scholars and contemporary moral philosophers. The basic premise of the manuscript is that, despite Hobbes’s materialism, he was committed to the existence of two irreducible and genuinely normative properties and types of claim, involving third-personal reasons for which one is responsible, and second-personal reasons for which one is accountable to others. As a result, despite widespread belief to the contrary, Hobbes cannot be fruitfully read as a substantive ethical naturalist for whom normative properties and claims are reducible to naturalistic, non-normative ones; nor was he is an expressivist or normative nihilist; nor was he a pure instrumentalist about practical reasons. Rational agents have genuine, irreducibly normative reasons to desire the preservation of a life worth living, and they have prudential reasons (independent of their desire to do so) to take the means that promote such an end; and rational agents who are also persons have genuine, irreducibly normative second-personal reasons to uphold their contracts, for which they are accountable to others. Moreover, Hobbes had neither a subjectivist (desire-fulfilment) theory of the good, nor a subjectivist theory of practical reasons. Reading Hobbes as an ethical naturalist, expressivist, or nihilist cannot properly account for his strongly cognitive account of reasoning, according to which reasoners infer conclusions by reasoning from premises that they take to furnish genuine, normative reasons; reading him as a pure instrumentalist about practical reasons fails to account for his commitment to prudential practical reasons (to care for one’s future self) and to a notion of obligation as a type of second-personal normative reason.|
Call for applications: The Groupe de recherche interuniversitaire en philosophie politique de Montréal (GRIPP), spanning the departments of political science and philosophy at McGill University, l’Université de Montréal, Concordia University, and l’Université du Québec à Montréal, invites applications for its 2016 manuscript workshop award. The recipient of the award will be invited to Montreal for a day-long workshop in May 2016 dedicated to his or her book manuscript. This “author meets critics” workshop will comprise four to five sessions dedicated to critical discussion of the manuscript; each session will begin with a critical commentary on a section of the manuscript by a political theorist or philosopher who is part of Montreal’s GRIPP community. The format is designed to maximize feedback for a book-in-progress. The award covers the costs of travel, accommodation, and meals.
- Topic: The manuscript topic is open within political theory and political philosophy.
- Manuscript: Book manuscripts in English or French, not yet in a version accepted for publication, by applicants with PhD in hand by 1 August 2015, are eligible. Applicants must have a complete or nearly complete draft (at least 4/5 of final draft) ready to present at the workshop. In the case of co-authored manuscripts, only one of the co-authors is eligible to apply. (Only works in progress by the workshop date are eligible; authors with a preliminary book contract are eligible only if no version has been already accepted for publication).
Application: Please submit the following materials electronically, compiled as a single PDF file, in the following order: 1) a curriculum vitae; 2) a table of contents; 3) a short abstract of the book project, up to 200 words; 4) a longer book abstract up to 2500 words; and, in the case of applicants with previous book publication(s), (5) three reviews, from established journals in the field, of the applicant’s most recently published monograph. Candidates are not required, but may if they wish, to have two letters of recommendation speaking to the merits of the book project submitted as well. Please do not send writing samples. The PDF file name should be your last name followed by a space and your first name. Send materials by email, with the subject heading “2016 GRIPP Manuscript Workshop Award” to Arash Abizadeh <arash.abizadeh at mcgill.ca>. Review of applications begins 15 January 2016. Contact Arash Abizadeh <arash.abizadeh at mcgill.ca> with questions.
Evaluation Process: The final decision for choosing the winner of the GRIPP manuscript award lies with the GRIPP Jury. The Jury will seek to meet within the first two weeks of the rolling deadline for submissions. All bilingual regular faculty members of GRIPP have the right to participate as members of the Jury. Each regular faculty member of GRIPP has the right to suggest a short-list of up to five proposals for consideration by the Jury, but the final decision rests with the Jury itself. All elements of the Jury’s deliberations are confidential; unfortunately it is not possible for the Jury or its members to provide any feedback to applicants concerning the merits of their proposal. A full list of the regular GRIPP faculty membership is available at <http://grippmontreal.org>
Previous GRIPP Manuscript Workshops:
August 2015: Lea Ypi (LSE) [with co-author Jonathan White (LSE)], The Meaning of Partisanship
May 2015: Magali Bessone (Rennes 1), Réparer les injustices coloniales : Perspective transitionnelle sur la justice réparatrice
May 2014: Paul Gowder (Iowa), A Commitment to Equality: The Rule of Law in the Real World
May 2013: Alex Gourevitch (McMaster), Something of Slavery Still Remains: Labor and the Cooperative Commonwealth
May 2012: Daniel Viehoff (Sheffield), The Authority of Democracy
May 2011: James Ingram (McMaster), Radical Cosmopolitics: The Ethics and Politics of Democratic Universalism
April 2010: Hélène Landemore (Yale), Democratic Reason: Politics, Collective Intelligence, and the Rule of the Many
April 2009: Alan Patten (Princeton), Equal Recognition: The Moral Foundations of Minority Cultural Rights
March 2009: Kinch Hoekstra (UC Berkeley), Thomas Hobbes and the Creation of Order
Call for Applications
The Groupe de recherche interuniversitaire en philosophie politique de Montréal (GRIPP) invites applications for a limited number of 2015-16 graduate student fellowships. Fellowships are available to graduate students in political philosophy and political theory at Concordia, McGill University, l’Université de Montréal, and l’Université de Québec à Montréal studying for their program’s highest degree.
Stipends will vary by degree program, by the Fellows’ existing funding, and by the number of successful applicants, but will be up to $6,000 for PhD students and $2,000 for MA students in programs that do not normally offer the PhD.
Successful applicants are expected to attend and participate in all GRIPP activities, including 2-3 seminars per month (held on Fridays), 1-2 conferences per year, two book manuscript workshops, and one workshop per semester on methods and approaches in political theory and philosophy. In all cases, papers will be circulated and should always be read in advance.
Fellows will be expected to either
a) present a manuscript in progress at a seminar, which must be circulated at least two weeks in advance, with an abstract available in both French and English. These papers, normally dissertation chapters or manuscripts in preparation for submission to conferences and journals, should be 6000-10,000 words in length, i.e. about the length of a journal article;
b) lead discussion of a manuscript in progress (which may be written by a Fellow, or a GRIPP-affiliated postdoc or faculty member, or a visiting speaker). This will involve speaking for 10-15 minutes at the beginning of the session. A straightforward summary of the paper isn’t called for, since all attendees should have read the paper, but rather an explanation and elaboration of its key arguments and contributions, followed by constructively critical engagement, suggestions for future directions, challenges, and questions. The aim is to help the author, and to provide a good starting point for useful discussion.
Applications must include:
-The name of at least one GRIPP faculty member (see list here http://grippmontreal.org/faculty/ ) who will support your application.
-For past GRIPP fellowship holders: a statement of progress made since obtaining the GRIPP fellowship.
-Information about any external or endowed fellowships you hold (agency and award). (Those who hold full fellowships will receive courtesy stipends, not the full award.)
Fellows in their first year with GRIPP will act as discussants; so will those who presented papers last year. Returning fellows who acted as discussants last year will present papers this year.
If you will be a discussant, you should indicate any broad preferences about the kind of work you are most interested in discussing (these may not be honoured) and whether you are able to comment on work that was written in French, English, or either.
If you will be presenting a paper, you should offer a tentative title and abstract of the paper, along with preferences about when in the year you would like to present (these may not be honoured, and you will be expected to present whenever your session is scheduled).
GRIPP is a bilingual research group. Workshops will operate according to the principle of passive bilingualism.
Deadline: August 21, 2015
Research Workshop on
The Meaning of Partisanship
Annual Montreal Political Theory Manuscript Workshop
with Lea Ypi & Jonathan White
Arts Council Room 160, McGill University
The Groupe de recherche en philosophie politique de Montréal (GRIPP) is pleased to announce a one-day workshop dedicated to the 2015 co-winner of the Annual Montreal Political Theory Manuscript Workshop Award, “The Meaning of Partisanship,” by Lea Ypi and Jonathan White of LSE.
GRIPP team member Christian Nadeau has been elected President of Quebec’s Ligue des droits et libertés.
Research Workshop on
Réparer les injustices coloniales
Perspective transitionnelle sur la justice réparatrice
Annual Montreal Political Theory Manuscript Workshop
Arts Council Room 160, McGill University
The Groupe de recherche en philosophie politique de Montréal (GRIPP) is pleased to announce a one-day workshop dedicated to the 2015 co-winner of the Annual Montreal Political Theory Manuscript Workshop Award, “Réparer les injustices coloniales: Propositions néo-républicaines pour une justice réparatrice,” by Magali Bessone of Université de Rennes 1. Read More
Congratulations to GRIPP/ RGCS postdoctoral fellow Caleb Yong, whose dissertation “Justice, Legitimacy, and Movement across Borders: A Political Theory of International Migration” has been recognized with the Sir Ernest Barker Prize for Best Dissertation in Political Theory by the Political Studies Association!
The Spring 2015 GRIPP conference, organized by Hasana Sharp, will be held April 24-25; full schedule and information at the link.
The Groupe de recherche en philosophie politique de Montréal (GRIPP) is pleased to announce that it has, exceptionally this year, made a joint nomination for the 2015 Annual Montreal Political Theory Manuscript Workshop Award. The 2015 will be shared by Lea Ypi of the Department of Government, LSE, for her manuscript “The Meaning of Partisanship” (co-authored with Jonathan White), and Magali Bessone of the UFR de Philosophie, Université de Rennes 1, for her manuscript “Réparer les injustices coloniales: Propositions néo-républicaines pour une justice réparatrice.” The workshop with Bessone will held in Montreal on May 4, 2015; the workshop with Ypi will held in the fall.